— State Farm Fire and Casualty Company has agreed to a $47.86 million settlement with the Oklahoma Insurance Department following an investigation that identified improper handling of homeowners' wind and hail damage claims. The agreement establishes a review process for potentially unpaid claims and requires the insurer to fund consumer restitution, storm mitigation grants and regulatory penalties.

The settlement follows a targeted market conduct examination in which independent engineers inspected 58 residential roofs associated with claims closed without payment. Engineers determined that 27 properties had storm-related damage warranting repair or replacement. In 22 of those cases, independent repair estimates exceeded the policyholder's deductible, contrary to State Farm's original claim determinations.

Regulators identified at least 22 instances in which State Farm failed to make a good-faith effort to settle roofing claims when liability had become reasonably clear. The examination also identified deficiencies involving written denial notices and the timely production of records requested by investigators.

Under the agreement announced Nov. 13, State Farm will deposit at least $35 million into an escrow account to support independent reviews and payments to eligible policyholders. Another $10 million will support Oklahoma's Strengthen Oklahoma Homes program, which provides grants for improvements designed to protect residences against severe weather. The insurer will separately pay $2.86 million in regulatory fines and examination expenses.

The claims review program covers eligible wind and hail losses dated between Jan. 1, 2021, and Dec. 31, 2025, that were closed without payment. State Farm must notify affected homeowners by Dec. 31, 2026, with instructions for requesting reconsideration. Policyholders will have 180 days after their initial notices to opt into the program.

An independent third-party administrator will examine original claim files, policy provisions and any additional documentation submitted by homeowners. Reviews will assess damage causation, coverage, repair costs and applicable deductibles. Independent adjusters and engineers may be consulted when additional expertise is needed.

Participation does not guarantee compensation. Claims approved for payment will be resolved according to the applicable insurance policies, subject to coverage limits and other provisions.

State Farm disputes the examination findings and denies violating insurance laws. The company maintains that it evaluates claims individually and has defended its handling of Oklahoma storm losses.

The settlement has also drawn criticism from Oklahoma Attorney General Gentner Drummond, who filed a separate lawsuit against State Farm in June 2026 alleging systematic improper denials of roof damage claims. Drummond argues that the agreement unfairly restricts homeowners' legal options by requiring those who accept compensation to release related claims against the insurer, including allegations of bad-faith conduct.

Insurance Commissioner Glen Mulready has defended the settlement as a means of obtaining compensation without requiring homeowners to pursue additional litigation. His department will oversee implementation of the review program, while the attorney general's lawsuit remains active.

Beyond the financial settlement, State Farm must provide quarterly reports to Oklahoma regulators detailing wind and hail claim activity, including claims closed without payment, amounts paid on approved claims and related litigation. The agreement also requires a corrective action plan addressing deficiencies identified during the examination.