Tavern Wins Court Fight for Covid Loss Insurance Coverage

A downtown Pittsburgh bar won a state court ruling that compels its insurance company to cover pandemic-related losses, scoring a rare business win over their insurers on Covid coverage.

Grant Street Tavern, owned by MacMiles LLC, had an all-risk policy from Erie Insurance Exchange covering ‘direct physical ‘loss’ of or damage to Covered Property,’ according to a ruling issued Tuesday by Judge Christine Ward of the Court of Common Pleas of Allegheny County.

Such a loss would include the tavern’s inability to use its premises due to Covid-19 safety concerns, Ward said.

Businesses nationwide have sued their insurers to seek coverage for financial losses stemming from Covid-19 related closures.

The tavern’s victory marks a rare court win for businesses, as judges have predominantly sided with insurers that claim policies exclude such coverage terms.

Claims Pages Staff Writers are dedicated professionals covering a broad spectrum of insurance topics, including auto, catastrophe, education & training, fraud, legislation, liability, life & health, litigation, property, risk management, technology, underwriting, and workers' compensation. With over 25 years of distribution, our publication brings you accurate and timely information to keep you informed and ahead in the claims industry.