Claims Pages
claimspages

Six Hours in a Conference Room

How Adjusters Prepare for a Deposition, What the Questions Are Designed to Do, and How to Answer Only What Was Asked

An adjuster can handle claims for years before the first deposition notice arrives. This article answers the questions adjusters ask before their first deposition and works through sample exchanges that show where testimony goes wrong.

— A deposition is a long conversation in which only one side asks questions and every word is written down. The adjuster sits at a conference table, or in front of a camera on a video call, with defense counsel beside them, the plaintiff's attorney across the table, a court reporter typing, and sometimes a videographer. The questions can run all day. Months later, pieces of the transcript may be read to a jury or quoted in a motion.

Adjusters preparing for a first deposition tend to ask the same questions. This article answers them in roughly the order they come up, with sample exchanges along the way. Every exchange below is an invented example. None is taken from a real transcript. Procedural details here follow the federal rules; state courts have their own versions, and defense counsel will explain the rules that apply.

Why am I being deposed if I am not the one being sued?

Usually because the adjuster is the person who knows what happened on the claim. In a bad-faith or breach-of-contract case, the plaintiff wants to hear from the people who made the decisions. In a liability case, the adjuster may be a witness to statements, photos, and the investigation.

Sometimes the adjuster is named personally. Some states allow a policyholder to sue an individual adjuster, and some limit those suits. Texas, for example, lets an insurer elect to accept whatever liability its adjuster might have on certain property claims, under Texas Insurance Code § 542A.006. That election can end the case against the adjuster, but the statute expects the insurer to make that adjuster available for deposition when noticed, and the insurer loses the statute's attorney's fee limits if it fails to, unless one of the statute's narrow exceptions applies. Either way, the adjuster may still be deposed.

Is the company's lawyer my lawyer?

Ask that question directly, and ask it early. Under ABA Model Rule 1.13, a lawyer retained by an organization represents the organization. The same rule lets that lawyer also represent an employee, subject to the conflict rules in Model Rule 1.7, and requires the lawyer to explain who the client is when the organization's interests are adverse to the employee's.

In most adjuster depositions, the carrier's counsel represents the adjuster for the deposition, and the interests line up. When they do not line up, for example when the carrier's defense may be that the adjuster ignored company guidelines, the adjuster may need separate counsel. An independent adjuster deposed in a carrier's case should also ask whether the IA firm's own counsel will be involved.

What should I review before the deposition?

Whatever defense counsel tells you to review, and nothing else without asking first. The reason is Federal Rule of Evidence 612. If a witness uses a writing to refresh memory while testifying, the other side is entitled to see it, cross-examine on it, and introduce relevant portions. If the witness used it before testifying, the court can order the same when "justice requires." A personal summary the adjuster typed up the night before, or a supervisor's email the adjuster pulled up to jog their memory, may end up as an exhibit.

Most preparation sessions cover the claim file in order, the key letters and estimates, the policy provisions at issue, and the carrier's guidelines the plaintiff is likely to ask about. Expect at least one practice session in which counsel asks hard questions. Treat it as practice for the hardest moments of the real thing.

How long will it take?

Under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 30(d)(1), a deposition is limited to "1 day of 7 hours" unless the parties agree or the court orders otherwise. That counts time on the record. Breaks, lunch, and off-the-record discussion add more. A deposition that starts at nine can easily run until five.

Ask for breaks when needed. The usual rule is that a witness should not take a break while a question is pending; answer the question first, then ask.

What happens in the first ten minutes?

The court reporter swears the witness in. The plaintiff's attorney then usually gives a set of instructions that sound like courtesy and work as groundwork: answer out loud because the reporter cannot record a nod, let me finish the question before you answer, tell me if you don't understand a question, and if you answer, I'll assume you understood it. That last one matters. An adjuster who answers a confusing question has, on the record, agreed that it was clear.

Background questions follow. Education, licenses, employers, training, how long the adjuster has handled this type of claim, and how many claims were on the desk at the time of this one. These questions feel routine, and the answers set up later ones. If the adjuster says they were trained on the carrier's guidelines, the next hour may be spent comparing the file to those guidelines. Answer accurately, and do not inflate or shrink experience.

What if the notice is addressed to the company?

That is a different kind of deposition. Rule 30(b)(6) lets a party notice an organization and list "with reasonable particularity the matters for examination." The organization designates someone to testify on its behalf, and that person must testify about information "known or reasonably available to the organization," not only what the designee personally knows.

An adjuster designated as a corporate representative is speaking for the carrier. Preparation for that role is longer and wider. It covers claim-handling guidelines, training, and topics the adjuster may never have touched on this file. "I don't know" from a designee can be treated as the company not knowing, which is why counsel will want the adjuster prepared on every listed topic.

What are the questions designed to do?

Most deposition questions do one of four things. They pin down facts, they establish a standard the adjuster agrees with, they test the file against that standard, or they get the witness to say more than was asked. The sample exchanges below show each one.

The standard-setting question sounds harmless.

Example exchange

Q. You'd agree that an insurer should always put its policyholder's interests first?

A. Yes, absolutely.

"Always" and "first" are doing the work. Once the adjuster agrees, every later decision that did not favor the insured can be measured against an absolute rule the adjuster accepted under oath. An accurate answer is narrower.

Example exchange

Q. You'd agree that an insurer should always put its policyholder's interests first?

A. I'd say an insurer has to treat the policyholder fairly and pay what the policy covers. I wouldn't use the word "always" for anything in claims.

The file test comes next, often by reading a note aloud.

Example exchange

Q. I'm showing you page 14 of the claim notes. Read the entry for March 9 out loud, please.

A. "Spoke w/ insd re: roof."

Q. What did you say to her about the roof?

A. I don't remember the specifics of that call.

Q. So there's no record anywhere of what you told her?

A. Not beyond that note, no.

That exchange is honest, and it is the best answer available, but the note left the adjuster nowhere to go. The first article in this series covers the note habits that prevent this exchange. The adjuster's job in the room is to tell the truth about what the file shows and what they remember, and nothing more. Guessing what was said, or reconstructing a conversation to sound better, is the wrong answer every time.

The question that invites a speech is the easiest to fall into.

Example exchange

Q. Did you inspect the attic?

A. No, but the field adjuster was supposed to, and honestly we were swamped after the storm, we had something like 400 claims on the desk, and the guidelines at the time didn't really require an attic inspection unless...

The question called for one word. The answer opened four new subjects: the field adjuster's performance, staffing, claim volume, and what the guidelines required. Each one will now get its own line of questioning. The accurate answer was "No." If there is more to say, defense counsel can ask follow-up questions later in the deposition.

The document the witness has never seen is the last common trap.

Example exchange

Q. This is the company's 2023 roof claim guideline. Under section 4, you were required to inspect the attic, weren't you?

A. May I read section 4 before I answer?

Q. Go ahead.

A. I've read it. I don't recall seeing this version of the guideline before today. The guideline I was trained on in 2022 didn't require an attic inspection on every roof claim. I don't know when this version took effect.

Ask to read any document before answering questions about it, and take the time to read it. Then answer only what the witness knows: whether they have seen it, when, and what it says. Counsel can establish which version applied with other witnesses and documents.

What if the attorney gets aggressive?

Some attorneys raise their voice, repeat a question five times, or rephrase an answer back in harsher words and ask the witness to agree. The tone is usually aimed at the transcript or the video, where a flustered or argumentative witness looks evasive. Keep the same pace and the same voice. If a rephrasing is wrong, say so and restate the original answer. If the same question is asked again, give the same answer again. Defense counsel will object if the questioning crosses a line, and Rule 30(d)(3) allows a motion to stop or limit a deposition conducted in bad faith or in a way that "unreasonably annoys, embarrasses, or oppresses" the witness.

What do I do when my lawyer objects?

Usually, answer the question anyway. Rule 30(c)(2) says objections are noted on the record "but the examination still proceeds; the testimony is taken subject to any objection." Objections must be "concise" and "nonsuggestive," so counsel will not use them to coach the answer. The judge rules on them later, if ever.

The exception is an instruction not to answer, which the same rule allows "only when necessary to preserve a privilege, to enforce a limitation ordered by the court," or to present a motion to limit the deposition. If counsel says "I'm instructing the witness not to answer," do not answer. That usually happens when a question asks about conversations with lawyers.

What if I realize I made a mistake?

Fix it as soon as you notice, on the record. "I want to correct something I said earlier about the inspection date" is a normal sentence in a deposition, and a correction made the same day carries more weight than one made a month later.

After the deposition, Rule 30(e) lets the witness, if review is requested before the deposition ends, take 30 days after the transcript is available to review it and sign a statement listing any changes "and the reasons for making them." Use that period to correct transcription errors and genuine mistakes. Substantive changes are attached to the transcript, and the other side can ask about them. An answer changed only because it hurt the case invites a new round of questions about the change.

The short version

Counsel will give the adjuster a fuller set of instructions. Most of them reduce to a handful of habits:

  • Listen to the whole question, pause, then answer

  • Answer only the question asked, and stop

  • If you do not understand the question, say so

  • If you do not know or do not remember, say that instead of guessing

  • Do not agree to "always," "never," or "every" unless it is true

  • Ask to see a document before answering questions about it

  • Do not volunteer documents, notes, or names that were not asked about

  • Correct mistakes on the record as soon as you notice them

  • Review only what counsel tells you to review, and bring nothing unless asked

  • Stay polite to the attorney asking the questions, however the day goes

The adjuster who follows those habits will still have a long day. The transcript, read later by a judge or jury, will show a witness who answered honestly and did not argue with anyone.

Sources

  1. Texas Legislature. Texas Insurance Code, Chapter 542A. Certain Consumer Actions Related to Claims for Property Damage. 2017.

  2. American Bar Association. Model Rules of Professional Conduct, Rule 1.13. Organization as Client.

  3. American Bar Association. Model Rules of Professional Conduct, Rule 1.7. Conflict of Interest: Current Clients.

  4. Cornell Law School, Legal Information Institute. Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 612. Writing Used to Refresh a Witness.

  5. Cornell Law School, Legal Information Institute. Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 30. Depositions by Oral Examination.