Claims Pages
claimspages
When Claims Become Cases

When Claims Become Cases

  Editorial Series   November 2026   Vol. 4 Issue. 9

Welcome to this month's editorial series, "When Claims Become Cases." A homeowner's claim closes in March with a partial denial. In September a letter arrives from a law firm asking for the complete claim file, including every note, email, photo, and text message. By the following spring, the adjuster who wrote "insd seems to be padding contents" in a hurry on a Friday afternoon is sitting across a conference table from the attorney who wants to know exactly what that meant.

This series follows the file from the first note to the deposition chair. We start with claim notes, because they are the record a regulator, a judge, and a jury will read, and we rewrite real-world note habits into entries that say what happened and when. We cover the first days after a letter of representation arrives, including who the adjuster can still talk to and what has to go out in writing. We walk through the litigation hold: the data sources a carrier is expected to preserve, and the texts, photos, and estimate drafts adjusters forget they own. We prepare for a deposition question by question. And we finish with the list defense counsel asks for in the first weeks of a lawsuit, so the adjuster can have it ready before the call.

The habits in these articles belong to adjusters, and most take a few extra seconds per entry. Each one assumes that a stranger may read the file out loud two years from now, with the adjuster in the room.

The File Note Will Be Read Aloud

How to Write Claim Notes That Hold Up When a Regulator, a Judge, or a Plaintiff's Attorney Reads Them Back to You

Claim notes are written for the next person on the file and read, years later, by people looking for a reason the claim went wrong. This article rewrites six common note habits into entries that record facts, dates, and reasons in plain language.
November 17 Chris Walters

The Day the Letter Says Attorney

What Changes in the First Seventy-Two Hours After a Letter of Representation Arrives on an Open Claim

A letter of representation changes who the adjuster talks to, what goes out in writing, and how every deadline on the file is tracked. This article walks through the first three days hour by hour, from the acknowledgment to the first status letter sent to counsel.
November 17 Chris Walters

The File Nobody Can Delete

Litigation Holds, Electronic Records, and the Texts, Photos, and Estimate Drafts That Count as Evidence

Once litigation is reasonably anticipated, a carrier has to preserve more than the claim system. This article is a checklist by data source, from the phone in the adjuster's pocket to the estimating platform's revision history.
November 17 Chris Walters

Six Hours in a Conference Room

How Adjusters Prepare for a Deposition, What the Questions Are Designed to Do, and How to Answer Only What Was Asked

An adjuster can handle claims for years before the first deposition notice arrives. This article answers the questions adjusters ask before their first deposition and works through sample exchanges that show where testimony goes wrong.
November 17 Chris Walters

What Defense Counsel Needs from the Adjuster

The Requests Counsel Makes in the First Weeks of a Lawsuit and the File Habits That Answer Them Before They Are Asked

Defense counsel inherits a claim file and has weeks to understand it. This article is the list counsel asks for, numbered in the order it is usually needed, and explains why each item matters to the defense.
November 17 Chris Walters