Claims Pages
claimspages

The Day the Letter Says Attorney

What Changes in the First Seventy-Two Hours After a Letter of Representation Arrives on an Open Claim

A letter of representation changes who the adjuster talks to, what goes out in writing, and how every deadline on the file is tracked. This article walks through the first three days hour by hour, from the acknowledgment to the first status letter sent to counsel.

— The letter is usually one page. It names the client, gives the claim number, and says that the firm now represents the insured or the claimant "with respect to all claims arising from" the loss. It asks that all future communication go through the firm. It often asks for a certified copy of the policy, the complete claim file, and every photo and recorded statement. Some letters add a request to preserve evidence. A few arrive with a demand and a deadline already attached.

The claim does not stop when that letter arrives. The adjuster still owes the same investigation, the same timelines, and the same good faith. What changes is the path every communication takes and the care with which the file is kept. This article follows the first seventy-two hours, because a mistake made in that window is hard to undo once a complaint is filed.

Carrier guidelines and state law vary, and the adjuster's own claims manual controls. The timeline below is a working order of operations that fits most property and casualty files.

Hour zero: read the whole letter

Before calling anyone, read the letter twice and answer five questions in a file note.

  1. Who does the firm represent? The insured, a third-party claimant, a tenant, a lienholder? A first-party letter from the insured's lawyer changes the adjuster's relationship with the policyholder. A third-party letter changes the relationship with the claimant and may also mean the insured is about to be sued.

  2. Which claim or claims does it cover? A letter about the bodily injury claim may not cover the property damage claim on the same loss. If the scope is unclear, ask counsel in writing.

  3. What exactly is being requested? List every item: policy, file, photos, statements, estimates, payment history.

  4. Is there a deadline? Time-limited demands, statutory notices, and presuit notices each have clocks that start on receipt.

  5. Does the letter ask the carrier to preserve evidence? If so, that request goes to the supervisor today.

Write the date and time the letter was received in the note. If it came by email, save the email itself, headers included, as well as the attachment. Receipt dates matter more after this point than they did before.

The first four hours: stop, route, and acknowledge

Stop direct contact with the represented person about the claim. The rule most adjusters have heard of is ABA Model Rule 4.2, which bars a lawyer from communicating about a matter with a person the lawyer knows is represented in it, without the other lawyer's consent. That rule binds lawyers, not adjusters, and the official comment to Rule 4.2 says parties to a matter may communicate directly with each other. In practice almost every carrier adopts the same line as a claims-handling rule, for good reason. A direct call after a letter of representation looks like an attempt to go around the lawyer, and it hands opposing counsel a story. The same comment also says a lawyer may not make a prohibited contact "through the acts of another," which matters once defense counsel is involved and asks the adjuster for help.

Tell everyone else on the file. The field adjuster, the independent appraiser, the contractor network, the desk reviewer, the salvage vendor, and anyone else who might pick up a phone needs to know that contact goes through counsel. Put the instruction in a note and in a short email to each person, and keep the emails.

If the represented person calls after the letter, be polite, say that the adjuster has received a letter from their attorney and needs to speak with the attorney about the claim, and end the call. Note the date, time, and what was said.

Then acknowledge the letter. The NAIC Unfair Claims Settlement Practices Act lists failing to acknowledge "pertinent communications" with reasonable promptness as an unfair practice, and most states set a specific number of days. A letter of representation is a pertinent communication. The acknowledgment can be short. Here is an example, not a form, and it should be adapted to the carrier's templates:

Thank you for your letter dated November 4 advising that you represent Ms. Lopez on the above claim. We will direct all further communication about this claim to your office. Our adjuster on this file is Dana Price, who can be reached at the number below. We are reviewing your request for documents and will respond separately. Please let us know whether your representation includes the contents portion of this claim as well as the dwelling.

Keep it factual. Leave out coverage positions, settlement talk, and anything about the merits. The acknowledgment is the first document counsel will attach to a complaint if things go badly, and it should read as calm and responsive.

By the end of day one: deadlines and supervisors

Build a deadline list for the file and put it in a note. The list should include every regulatory clock still running on the claim, every date in the letter, and any statutory presuit period that applies in the state of the loss. Two examples show how different those clocks can be.

In Texas, a first-party property claim caused by weather or other forces of nature falls under Texas Insurance Code Chapter 542A. The claimant generally has to give written notice at least 61 days before filing suit, stating the specific amount alleged to be owed and the attorney's fees incurred so far. The insurer then has 30 days from receiving that notice to ask in writing to inspect, photograph, or evaluate the property. The statute lets the insurer abate a suit when a timely inspection request was refused, so a request sent on day 31 gives up that remedy.

In Florida, suits under residential and commercial property policies fall under Florida Statutes § 627.70152. The claimant files a notice of intent to initiate litigation through the state's Department of Financial Services at least 10 business days before suit, and the insurer must respond in writing within 10 business days. Depending on what the notice alleges, the response has to accept coverage, continue to deny, assert the right to reinspect, make a settlement offer, or require appraisal or another form of alternative dispute resolution. Ten business days goes quickly when the adjuster first has to find the notice in a shared inbox.

Other states have their own presuit and time-limited demand rules, and some letters of representation are, in substance, one of those notices. When in doubt about whether a letter starts a statutory clock, escalate it the same day and let the carrier's coverage counsel decide.

Notify the supervisor and follow the carrier's referral rules. Many carriers require a litigation or attorney-involvement referral, a reserve review, and in some cases notice to reinsurers or excess carriers. For a third-party letter, check whether the insured has been told about the claim and whether the insured needs to be warned that a suit may follow. The insured is still the carrier's customer and is not the represented party.

Day two: the file request and the preservation question

Counsel's request for "the complete claim file" is not a court order, and adjusters should not send the file out the door on their own. What can be produced, when, and with what redactions depends on state law, the line of business, and whether the claimant is the insured or a third party. Insureds are often entitled to a certified copy of their policy. Internal reserve information, coverage opinions from counsel, and notes made at counsel's direction are handled differently. Route the request to whoever at the carrier decides production, and note that it was routed.

The preservation question cannot wait for that decision. Once litigation is reasonably anticipated, the carrier has a duty to keep relevant information. The federal rule that addresses lost electronic information, Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 37(e), applies to information "that should have been preserved in the anticipation or conduct of litigation." A letter of representation does not always mean litigation is reasonably anticipated, but a letter that asks for preservation, threatens suit, or accompanies a presuit notice usually does. The Sedona Conference Commentary on Legal Holds places the trigger at notice of "a credible probability" that the organization will become involved in litigation, judged in good faith on the facts known at the time. Ask the supervisor whether a legal hold is being issued, and in the meantime do not delete anything. The third article in this series covers the hold in detail.

Day three: the status letter and the next diary

By the third day the adjuster should send counsel a short status letter. It confirms what the carrier has done so far, what is still outstanding, and what the carrier needs from counsel's client to keep the claim moving. If the claim was waiting on documents from the insured, the request now goes to counsel, restated in full with a date. If an inspection or reinspection is needed, propose dates.

This letter does two jobs. It keeps the claim moving, which is still the adjuster's duty. It also puts the outstanding items in front of counsel in writing, so a later complaint about delay can be measured against what was asked for and when.

Then set the next diary, and keep the regulatory status-letter schedule running. Representation does not pause most of those obligations. Some rules do change. California's 10 CCR § 2695.7(f), for example, requires written notice of an approaching statute of limitations to claimants, but expressly does not apply to a claimant represented by counsel on the claim. That is the kind of change an adjuster should confirm against the state's rules rather than assume.

When the letter is not from a lawyer

Not every representation letter comes from a law firm. Public adjusters, contractors holding an assignment of benefits, and family members with a power of attorney all send letters asking the carrier to deal with them instead of the insured. Rule 4.2 concerns people represented by a lawyer, so it does not reach any of these arrangements. State law decides what each one can do.

For a public adjuster, confirm the license in the state of the loss and get a copy of the signed contract, if state law allows the carrier to request one. For an assignment of benefits, get the assignment itself and check it against the state's current assignment rules before relying on it. For a power of attorney, get the document and confirm it covers insurance matters. In each case, note what was received and who the carrier will now communicate with, and continue to send required notices to the named insured unless state law or the policy says otherwise.

These letters can also be early signals of litigation. A public adjuster's letter that disputes the scope and mentions an attorney "if necessary" belongs in the same supervisor conversation about preservation as a lawyer's letter.

What the file should show at hour seventy-two

When the third day ends, a reader opening the file should find:

  • The letter, saved as received, with the date and time of receipt noted

  • A note answering who is represented, on which claims, what was requested, and by when

  • Written instructions to everyone on the file to stop direct contact

  • The acknowledgment letter to counsel

  • A deadline list that includes any statutory presuit or demand clock

  • The supervisor referral and any reserve review

  • A note that the file request was routed for a production decision

  • A note on the preservation question and any legal hold issued

  • The status letter to counsel with outstanding items and proposed dates

  • A diary date

Every item on that list is ordinary claim work, done in writing and a little faster than usual. The lawsuit, if it comes, will be about decisions made months earlier. The first seventy-two hours decide whether the file shows a carrier that kept working the claim after the lawyer showed up.

Sources

  1. American Bar Association. Model Rules of Professional Conduct, Rule 4.2. Communication with Person Represented by Counsel.

  2. American Bar Association. Model Rules of Professional Conduct, Rule 4.2, Comment.

  3. National Association of Insurance Commissioners. Unfair Claims Settlement Practices Act (Model 900). 1997.

  4. Texas Legislature. Texas Insurance Code, Chapter 542A. Certain Consumer Actions Related to Claims for Property Damage. 2017.

  5. Florida Legislature. Florida Statutes § 627.70152. Suits Arising Under a Property Insurance Policy. 2026.

  6. Cornell Law School, Legal Information Institute. Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 37. Failure to Make Disclosures or to Cooperate in Discovery; Sanctions.

  7. The Sedona Conference. The Sedona Conference Commentary on Legal Holds, Second Edition: The Trigger & The Process. June 2019.

  8. Cornell Law School, Legal Information Institute. Cal. Code Regs. Tit. 10, § 2695.7. Standards for Prompt, Fair and Equitable Settlements.