Claims Pages
claimspages

The File Nobody Can Delete

Litigation Holds, Electronic Records, and the Texts, Photos, and Estimate Drafts That Count as Evidence

Once litigation is reasonably anticipated, a carrier has to preserve more than the claim system. This article is a checklist by data source, from the phone in the adjuster's pocket to the estimating platform's revision history.

— Ask an adjuster where the claim file lives and the answer is usually the claim system. Ask a plaintiff's attorney the same question and the answer is longer. It includes the adjuster's work phone and the text thread with the contractor, the original photos on the camera card, the three versions of the estimate before the one that was sent, the voicemail the insured left on a Saturday, and the engineer's draft report that said something slightly different from the final one.

When litigation is reasonably anticipated, all of that is evidence, and the carrier has a duty to keep it. The tool for doing that is a legal hold, a written instruction from the carrier, usually through its legal department, telling the people who have relevant information to stop deleting it. Adjusters do not decide when a hold issues. They do decide, every day, whether the information it covers still exists when the hold arrives.

Why it matters to the adjuster

The federal rule on lost electronic information, Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 37(e), applies when information that "should have been preserved in the anticipation or conduct of litigation is lost because a party failed to take reasonable steps to preserve it" and cannot be recovered another way. If the loss prejudices the other side, the court may order measures "no greater than necessary to cure the prejudice." If the court finds the party acted with "the intent to deprive another party of the information's use in the litigation," it may presume the lost information was unfavorable, tell the jury it may or must make that presumption, or dismiss the case or enter a default judgment. State courts apply their own spoliation rules, and some are broader.

For an adjuster, the practical consequence is simpler than the rule. A deleted text thread becomes a question in a deposition: what was in it, why is it gone, and who decided. "My phone auto-deletes messages after thirty days" is an honest answer and a bad one, because it means nobody changed the setting when the claim turned adversarial.

The legal discovery rules also reach farther than many adjusters expect. Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 34 covers electronically stored information "including writings, drawings, graphs, charts, photographs, sound recordings, images, and other data or data compilations" in any medium. Lawyers are bound as well. ABA Model Rule 3.4(a) bars a lawyer from unlawfully destroying or concealing material "having potential evidentiary value," or from counseling or assisting anyone else to do so. Defense counsel cannot help clean up a file and will not try.

When the hold starts

The Sedona Conference, a nonprofit legal research institute, publishes guidelines on legal holds that say a reasonable anticipation of litigation arises when an organization "is on notice of a credible probability that it will become involved in litigation." A claim by itself is not that notice, since nearly every claim carries some theoretical chance of a lawsuit. Common signals on a claim file include a letter of representation that threatens suit or asks for preservation, a statutory presuit notice, a demand with a deadline, a complaint to the insurance department that alleges bad faith, and a summons.

The Sedona guidelines also recommend a procedure for reporting possible litigation "to a responsible decision maker." On most claim desks, that person is the supervisor or the litigation unit. The adjuster's job is to report the signal the day it arrives and to stop routine deletion of anything connected to the claim until someone decides.

The checklist, by data source

Each section below lists what to preserve and the usual way it gets lost. Carrier systems and policies differ. Where the carrier's legal hold notice or IT department gives a specific instruction, follow that instruction over this list.

The claim system

  • File notes, including notes later corrected

  • Diary entries and task history

  • Reserve history and the notes supporting each change

  • Payment history, including voided and reissued checks

  • Uploaded documents, with their upload dates

  • The audit trail, if the system keeps one

The claim system is usually the safest place in the file, because the carrier controls it and its records are kept by default. The risk is editing. A note changed after the hold, even to fix a typo, will show up in the audit trail and need explaining. Add new notes instead.

Email

  • The adjuster's mailbox, including sent items and deleted items

  • Shared claim inboxes and team mailboxes

  • Emails with vendors, experts, contractors, public adjusters, and counsel

  • Attachments as sent, which may differ from later versions in the file

Email is lost through retention policies. Many carriers purge mail after a set period, and individual users set their own rules. The legal department normally suspends automatic deletion for custodians under a hold, and the Sedona guidelines specifically mention "auto delete functionality that should be suspended." Do not wait for that to happen. Move claim email into the claim system, or into a folder that is not subject to auto-delete, as soon as a signal appears.

The phone

  • Text messages and messaging-app threads with anyone connected to the claim

  • Call logs

  • Voicemails

  • Photos and videos taken on the phone

  • Notes apps, voice memos, and screenshots

The phone is where most preservation failures happen, because it feels personal even when the carrier issued it. Messages disappear when an auto-delete setting is on, when the phone is replaced or reset, and when the adjuster leaves the company and turns the device in. Check the message-retention setting today and set it to keep messages. If any claim communication happened on a personal phone, tell the supervisor; personal devices can fall under a hold too. Better still, stop texting about claims on a personal phone at all.

A text thread with a contractor that says "can you get me a lower number on the roof" can be explained in context. The same thread, deleted, cannot be explained at all.

Photos and video

  • Original image files from the camera, phone, or drone, with their metadata

  • Every photo taken, including blurry and duplicate shots

  • Drone flight logs and raw video

  • Photos received from the insured, contractors, and mitigation vendors, as received

Photos are lost when only a selection is uploaded, or when upload compresses the files and strips the date, time, and location data. A plaintiff's expert may want the original files specifically to check when and where they were taken. Keep the full set, in original format, and keep the card or device until the hold says otherwise.

The estimating platform

  • Every version of the estimate, including drafts never sent

  • Revision history and change logs

  • The price list and date used for each version

  • Sketches and diagrams

  • Reviewer comments and desk-review changes

Estimate drafts are the part of the file adjusters most often forget they own. An estimate that went from $41,000 in draft to $28,000 as sent will draw questions. There may be a good reason, such as a scope corrected after the engineer's report. The revision history is how that reason gets shown. Do not delete drafts or old versions, and save the reason for each significant revision in a note.

Recorded statements and call recordings

  • Recorded statements, in original audio format

  • Transcripts and any summaries

  • Recorded customer-service and claim-line calls

Call-center recordings are often kept on a short retention schedule by a different department. The adjuster may not even know a call was recorded. Ask the supervisor to confirm that the legal hold reaches the telephone system.

Paper

  • Field notes, notebooks, and handwritten measurements

  • Printed photos with handwriting on them

  • Mail received and copies of mail sent

Field notes are thrown out once they are typed into the system. Under a hold, keep the originals. The handwritten version is sometimes the most contemporaneous record of what the adjuster saw.

Vendors and experts

  • Independent adjusting firm files, including the field adjuster's notes and photos

  • Engineer and cause-and-origin expert files, field notes, and drafts

  • Mitigation and remediation records, including moisture logs

  • Contractor and appraiser correspondence

Information held by vendors the carrier hired is often within the carrier's control for discovery purposes. Send each vendor a written preservation request through whatever channel the carrier uses, and note when it went out. Draft reports are a common point of dispute; ask the legal department how the carrier handles them instead of telling the expert to discard them.

Physical evidence

  • Failed components, such as supply lines, valves, water heaters, and fittings

  • Roofing samples, shingles, and material samples

  • Fire debris and anything removed for testing

  • Chain-of-custody records for each item

Physical evidence is lost when a mitigation crew throws out the failed part, when salvage disposes of it, or when the item is released to the insured. If a component may be tied to subrogation or to a coverage dispute, tag it, photograph it, store it, and record every hand it passes through.

Departures, new phones, and system changes

Three ordinary events can destroy claim evidence without anyone intending it.

The first is an adjuster leaving. When an employee or an independent adjuster leaves, the mailbox is often deleted on a schedule, the phone is wiped and reissued, and the laptop is reimaged. If that adjuster is a custodian under a hold, the legal department needs to know before the exit process starts. An adjuster who is leaving should tell their supervisor which open files have signals of litigation, and which devices hold information on them.

The second is a phone upgrade. Messages, photos, and voicemails do not always transfer to a new device, and the old one is usually returned or traded in. Before upgrading, back up the old phone through the carrier's approved method, confirm the claim messages and photos are on the new device or in the backup, and keep the old phone until IT says it can go.

The third is a system migration. Carriers replace claim systems, estimating platforms, and email providers. Old data is sometimes archived in a format that drops audit trails or attachments. The legal department and IT handle this, but an adjuster who notices that old notes or estimate versions are missing after a migration should report it in writing right away.

What a hold does not change

A hold stops deletion. It does not stop the claim. If the claim is still open, the adjuster keeps investigating, writing notes, sending letters, and making payments that are owed. New documents created after the hold are covered by it as well, so the same care applies to them.

A hold also does not make old documents better or worse. An unhelpful email from last spring is still in the file. Defense counsel can work with that email when it is preserved and produced in context. Counsel cannot defend its disappearance.

What the notice and the file should show

The Sedona guidelines describe an effective hold notice as one that identifies the people most likely to have relevant information, explains how to preserve it, names someone who can answer questions, asks recipients to acknowledge it, and is followed by reminders. If the adjuster receives a hold notice, acknowledge it the same day and keep the acknowledgment. If the notice misses a data source the adjuster knows about, such as a vendor or a phone, say so in writing to the person who sent it.

A hold also ends. The guidelines call for releasing a hold when the duty to preserve ends, so normal retention can resume. Routine claim-file retention rules, such as California's requirement in 10 CCR § 2695.3 that files be kept for the current year and the four preceding years, apply again after release. Until the legal department releases the hold in writing, keep everything.

The adjuster who walks into a deposition with a complete file, every draft, every photo, and every text intact, will still be asked hard questions. None of them will be about what happened to the evidence.

Sources

  1. Cornell Law School, Legal Information Institute. Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 37. Failure to Make Disclosures or to Cooperate in Discovery; Sanctions.

  2. Cornell Law School, Legal Information Institute. Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 34. Producing Documents, Electronically Stored Information, and Tangible Things, or Entering onto Land, for Inspection and Other Purposes.

  3. American Bar Association. Model Rules of Professional Conduct, Rule 3.4. Fairness to Opposing Party and Counsel.

  4. The Sedona Conference. The Sedona Conference Commentary on Legal Holds, Second Edition: The Trigger and The Process (Handout). June 2019.

  5. Cornell Law School, Legal Information Institute. Cal. Code Regs. Tit. 10, § 2695.3. File and Record Documentation.