Claims Pages
claimspages

What Defense Counsel Needs from the Adjuster

The Requests Counsel Makes in the First Weeks of a Lawsuit and the File Habits That Answer Them Before They Are Asked

Defense counsel inherits a claim file and has weeks to understand it. This article is the list counsel asks for, numbered in the order it is usually needed, and explains why each item matters to the defense.

— A defense lawyer assigned to a new suit starts with a complaint, a deadline to answer it, and whatever the adjuster sends. The lawyer did not see the loss, did not talk to the insured, and does not know which of the 300 pages in the file matter. The adjuster knows all of that. The first few weeks of the case go better or worse depending on how fast the adjuster can hand that knowledge over in a form counsel can use.

This article covers two common situations. In the first, the carrier has appointed counsel to defend its insured against a third-party suit. In the second, the carrier itself has been sued by its policyholder, and counsel represents the carrier. Most of the list applies to both. Where it differs, the item says so.

Who counsel works for

When a carrier hires a lawyer to defend its insured, the insured is the client, even though the carrier pays the bills. ABA Model Rule 1.8(f) allows a lawyer to accept payment from someone other than the client only if the client gives informed consent, there is "no interference with the lawyer's independence of professional judgment," and the client's information is protected under Model Rule 1.6. States treat the carrier's own relationship with defense counsel differently, and some treat the carrier as a co-client.

For the adjuster, this has practical consequences. Defense counsel will not help the carrier build a coverage defense against the insured, and should not be asked to. If the carrier is defending under a reservation of rights, coverage questions go to separate coverage counsel. Defense counsel may also decline to report facts that could hurt the insured on coverage. Under Model Rule 1.7, a lawyer cannot take on a representation materially limited by duties to a third person without the client's informed consent, and the carrier is that third person. Adjusters who understand that limit write cleaner assignment letters and get fewer awkward phone calls.

The assignment letter

The first document counsel receives from the adjuster is the assignment, and its quality sets the pace for everything after. A good assignment letter is short, factual, and complete enough that counsel can calendar the answer deadline and start reading the file the same day. The example below is an invented assignment for a third-party suit, and carriers will have their own templates:

We are assigning you to defend our insured, Riverside Property Management LLC, in Garcia v. Riverside Property Management, filed in the county circuit court on October 30 and served on the insured November 3. The suit alleges a slip and fall on an icy walkway at 1400 Elm Street on January 12.

The policy is a commercial general liability policy with a $1,000,000 per-occurrence limit. We are defending under a reservation of rights dated November 6 (attached); coverage questions are being handled separately by coverage counsel, and you should not report to us on coverage issues. Our insured contact is the property manager, Alan Reyes, at the number below.

Attached are the certified policy, the claim notes through today, the recorded statements of the claimant and Mr. Reyes, 42 scene photos in original format, the snow-removal contract, and the claimant's demand letter of September 18. A legal hold was issued to our claim staff and the snow-removal vendor on September 20. Please send your initial evaluation within 30 days under our litigation guidelines.

Every sentence in that letter answers a question counsel would otherwise have to ask: who the client is, what the suit alleges, what limits apply, whether there is a reservation, who to call, what is attached, whether evidence was preserved, and when the first report is due.

Bad facts belong in a phone call, made early. If the file has a gap, a note the adjuster wishes they had not written, a missed deadline, or a vendor who threw out the failed part, tell counsel directly in the first week. Counsel can plan around a problem they hear about from the adjuster. A problem they first read about in the plaintiff's motion costs the client more.

The list

Counsel's first request is usually some version of "send me everything." The list below breaks "everything" into the pieces counsel needs, roughly in the order the case needs them. The first several items feed the answer to the complaint and the initial disclosures. Under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 26(a)(1), those disclosures are generally due within 14 days after the parties' planning conference, and they include the names of people likely to have discoverable information, a copy or description of supporting documents, and "any insurance agreement" that may cover a judgment. State courts set their own timelines, and many are as short.

  1. The complete, certified policy. The declarations, every form, every endorsement, and the policy period at issue, plus any renewals if the loss date is in dispute. In a third-party case, the policy goes into the initial disclosures. In a first-party case, it is the contract being sued on. Send the certified copy, not the one in the claim file, which may be missing an endorsement.

  2. Every coverage letter. Acknowledgments, reservation-of-rights letters, denial letters, and any supplemental positions, with the dates sent and proof of delivery. In a bad-faith case, these letters are usually the core exhibits. In a defense case, counsel needs to know immediately whether the defense is under a reservation.

  3. The claim notes, exported with timestamps. The full note history, in order, as the system records it, including corrections. Counsel will read every entry, because opposing counsel will. If there are entries that need explaining, say so now, in a phone call, before counsel finds them alone.

  4. A chronology. A list of key dates: loss, report, inspection, each estimate, each payment, each letter, the letter of representation, any demand. Ask counsel how to prepare it. Counsel will often want it addressed to counsel and marked as prepared at counsel's request, because Rule 26(b)(3) protects materials prepared "in anticipation of litigation or for trial" in a way it does not protect the routine claim file.

  5. A list of people. Everyone with knowledge of the claim, with role, contact information, and what they know: the insured, household members, witnesses, every adjuster who touched the file, desk reviewers, supervisors who approved decisions, engineers, contractors, mitigation vendors, appraisers, and the public adjuster if there was one. Note anyone who has left the company. Counsel needs this for the initial disclosures and for deciding whose deposition to prepare for.

  6. Photos, video, and recorded statements, in original format. The full set, not a selection, with original files and metadata. Compressed copies pulled from a report are not enough if authenticity is challenged.

  7. Every version of the estimate, with the reason for each revision. An estimate that changed significantly between draft and final will draw questions. Counsel wants to hear the reason from the adjuster before hearing a theory about it from the plaintiff.

  8. Expert and vendor files. Engineer and cause-and-origin reports, engagement letters, invoices, and correspondence. Tell counsel whether drafts exist. Counsel decides how drafts and communications with experts will be handled.

  9. Demands, offers, and their deadlines. Every settlement demand, every offer, and every response, with the date received and date sent. Time-limited demands go to the top of the list. In a third-party case where damages may exceed the limits, counsel's view on exposure matters to the carrier's settlement decision. California's 10 CCR § 2695.7(g) lists, among the factors in judging whether a settlement offer was unreasonably low, "the extent to which the insurer considered the advice of its counsel that there was a substantial likelihood of recovery in excess of policy limits." The adjuster should read counsel's exposure analysis and respond to it in writing.

  10. Preservation status. Whether a legal hold was issued, when, and to whom, and anything that has already been lost, such as a phone that was replaced or a part that was discarded. Under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 37(e), the consequences of lost electronic information depend partly on whether reasonable steps were taken to keep it. Counsel can deal with a gap they know about. A gap discovered by the other side is much harder to handle.

  11. Prior losses and related claims. Prior claims on the same property or by the same claimant, and any related claims on the same loss, such as a separate contents claim or a claim under another policy. Counsel needs to know about them before they come up in discovery.

  12. Settlement authority and who holds it. Who can approve what amount, and how fast. Mediation is often scheduled before counsel expects it, and a mediator's proposal can expire while it waits three days for someone with authority to read it.

  13. The adjuster's own availability. Planned leave, upcoming transfers, a departure from the company. Depositions get scheduled around witnesses, and a departing adjuster should be prepared before leaving, not tracked down later.

What not to send, and how not to send it

Two habits protect the privilege that attaches to communications with counsel.

First, keep counsel's emails and reports inside the carrier. Forwarding a defense report to a vendor, a broker, or the insured's contractor can waive the privilege over that report. When a protected document goes out by mistake, Federal Rule of Evidence 502(b) provides that an inadvertent disclosure in a federal proceeding does not waive the privilege if the holder "took reasonable steps to prevent disclosure" and "promptly took reasonable steps to rectify the error." The second condition depends on the adjuster telling counsel the same day a mistake is noticed.

Second, keep counsel's advice out of the general claim notes. A note that says "Defense counsel thinks liability is 70/30 against us and recommends settling at $250,000" puts privileged advice into a business record that may be produced. Most carriers have a separate, restricted place for litigation and counsel communications. Use it, and use the regular notes for facts and actions: "Received defense counsel's case evaluation dated 3/14, filed in the litigation section."

When the adjuster disagrees with counsel

Adjusters and defense counsel disagree regularly, about valuation, about whether to take a deposition, about when to settle. The disagreement is normal, and the file should show how it was resolved.

Put the disagreement in writing, addressed to counsel, in the litigation section of the file. State the adjuster's view and the facts behind it: "Your evaluation puts verdict range at $150,000 to $300,000. Our medical review found that $60,000 of the billed treatment followed a gap of five months. Please address whether that gap changes your range." Then let counsel respond. In a third-party defense, remember whose lawyer counsel is. Counsel's duty runs to the insured, and decisions about how to defend the case belong to counsel and the client. The carrier's lever is the settlement decision, which it should make with counsel's analysis in front of it and a written record of why it chose as it did.

If the disagreement is about something counsel will not discuss, such as a fact bearing on coverage, that is a sign the question belongs with coverage counsel.

The reporting rhythm after the first month

After the initial handoff, defense counsel reports on a schedule set by the carrier's litigation guidelines: an initial case evaluation, reports after significant depositions and motions, and a pre-trial or pre-mediation report. Each one deserves a written response from the adjuster, even a short one. A report that sits unanswered in the file looks, later, like a carrier that was not paying attention to its own case.

Most of the thirteen items on the list above already exist in a well-kept file. The difference between a hard first month and an easy one is whether the adjuster can find them, explain them, and send them in a single organized package within a few days of assignment.

Sources

  1. American Bar Association. Model Rules of Professional Conduct, Rule 1.8. Current Clients: Specific Rules.

  2. American Bar Association. Model Rules of Professional Conduct, Rule 1.6. Confidentiality of Information.

  3. American Bar Association. Model Rules of Professional Conduct, Rule 1.7. Conflict of Interest: Current Clients.

  4. Cornell Law School, Legal Information Institute. Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 26. Duty to Disclose; General Provisions Governing Discovery.

  5. Cornell Law School, Legal Information Institute. Cal. Code Regs. Tit. 10, § 2695.7. Standards for Prompt, Fair and Equitable Settlements.

  6. Cornell Law School, Legal Information Institute. Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 37. Failure to Make Disclosures or to Cooperate in Discovery; Sanctions.

  7. Cornell Law School, Legal Information Institute. Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 502. Attorney-Client Privilege and Work Product; Limitations on Waiver.