Virginia Court Denies Workers’ Compensation for Dean Injured in Hallway Fall

Mary Pat O’Brien, the dean of nursing at Northern Virginia Community College, will not receive workers’ compensation benefits after a fall in a hallway. The Virginia Court of Appeals upheld the denial, agreeing with the Workers’ Compensation Commission (WCC) and a deputy commissioner. O’Brien argued that her fall was caused by a distraction from a colleague while walking to a meeting, resulting in a serious injury. However, the court found no evidence of an environmental factor contributing to the accident.

The court concluded that the injury did not arise out of her employment, stating that walking and turning were not employment-related risks. The WCC had previously determined that O’Brien’s action of turning to speak to a colleague was ordinary human behavior and did not constitute a work-related hazard. Additionally, there was no proof that holding work items contributed to her fall. The court ultimately ruled that her injury was an equal risk to anyone walking inattentively and did not warrant compensation benefits.

Claims Pages Staff Writers are dedicated professionals covering a broad spectrum of insurance topics, including auto, catastrophe, education & training, fraud, legislation, liability, life & health, litigation, property, risk management, technology, underwriting, and workers' compensation. With over 25 years of distribution, our publication brings you accurate and timely information to keep you informed and ahead in the claims industry.