Texas Supreme Court Dismisses Stonewater Roofing’s Claims Against Insurance Regulations (Texas Supreme Court)

Texas Supreme Court Dismisses Stonewater Roofing’s Claims Against Insurance Regulations

Tuesday, June 11th, 2024 Insurance Industry Legislation & Regulation Litigation Risk Management

The Texas Supreme Court ruled against Stonewater Roofing, a contractor challenging state regulations that require public insurance adjusters to be licensed. The case centered on whether these regulations infringed on free speech and due process rights. Stonewater Roofing argued that the licensing and dual-capacity prohibitions were unconstitutional under the First and Fourteenth Amendments.

The court upheld the Texas Department of Insurance’s (TDI) stance that these regulations govern professional conduct, not speech. Justice John P. Devine, writing for the majority, clarified that the statutes in question focus on the roles individuals play in nonexpressive commercial transactions and do not restrict protected speech. The court also found that the statutes were clear enough to dismiss both facial and as-applied vagueness challenges.

The ruling emphasized that contractors cannot act as both adjuster and contractor for the same property, preventing conflicts of interest. The decision reaffirms the state’s authority to regulate the insurance industry to protect consumers from potential exploitation, particularly in the aftermath of catastrophic events.


Claims Pages Staff Writers are dedicated professionals covering a broad spectrum of insurance topics, including auto, catastrophe, education & training, fraud, legislation, liability, life & health, litigation, property, risk management, technology, underwriting, and workers' compensation. With over 25 years of distribution, our publication brings you accurate and timely information to keep you informed and ahead in the claims industry.


External References & Further Reading
https://search.txcourts.gov/Case.aspx?cn=22-0427&coa=cossup

Mid-America Catastrophe ServicesHancock Claims Consultants LLCChurchill Claims Services

  Recent Provider Listings

Serving Santa Clara County
California Contractors General Drywall Contractors Water Damage
Serving Kentucky Statewide - CLM Member
Kentucky Attorneys & Law Firms
Serving Massachusetts, Connecticut & Rhode Island
Connecticut Massachusetts Rhode Island Fire Investigations