Mulch: An Overlooked Fire Hazard in California’s Landscaping

Monday, July 22nd, 2024 Catastrophe Insurance Industry Property Risk Management

In California, the risk of wildfires is both imminent and escalating. A common landscaping choice—mulch—has emerged as an overlooked fire hazard that many homeowners inadvertently invite into their yards. Made from organic materials like wood chips and bark, mulch can easily ignite and create a dangerous ‘fuel source’ right next to residences.

California’s unique climate, with hot, dry summers and seasonal Santa Ana winds, creates ideal conditions for wildfires. Drought and rising temperatures, compounded by human activities such as poor landscaping practices, have led to increasingly devastating fire seasons. Between 2018 and 2022, wildfires caused approximately $39 billion in losses for insurers, with four of the five costliest fires occurring in California. The growing urban-wildland interface, where homes are built near natural landscapes, exacerbates this danger. The widespread use of mulch for aesthetic appeal has intensified the risk associated with this landscaping choice.

Mulch, though common in many California gardens, poses significant risks. Organic materials are highly flammable, and dry conditions can lead to mulch igniting from small sparks from sources like campfires, discarded cigarettes, or lawnmowers. Once lit, mulch fires can quickly spread to nearby structures, creating perilous situations for homeowners and firefighters. An experiment at the Pacific Coast Builders Conference in Anaheim demonstrated this risk. Two identical structures were constructed—one surrounded by combustible mulch and the other with fire-resistant materials. The structure with mulch was quickly engulfed in flames, highlighting the severe implications mulch can have on home safety.

With the potential for catastrophic losses looming, insurance companies are re-evaluating their policies concerning homes in wildfire-prone areas. Many insurers are now reluctant to issue new policies or renew existing ones without significant changes to building and landscaping practices. Insurers are advocating for homes to adopt fire-resistant materials, better management of surrounding vegetation, and the removal of combustible landscaping features, including mulch. Josh Wilkins, a consultant from Idaho, notes that insurers aim to reduce wildfire risk by at least 20% before considering coverage in high-risk areas. Advanced predictive models from analytics firms like CoreLogic assess risks at a granular level, helping insurers determine premiums and coverage availability by analyzing factors such as rainfall, vegetation, wind patterns, and human activity.

To mitigate the risk associated with mulch, homeowners are urged to reconsider their landscaping choices. Here are some actionable steps:

• Limit the Use of Mulch: Opt for non-combustible alternatives like gravel or stone in landscaping designs.


• Create Defensible Space: Maintain a buffer zone around your home by clearing dry vegetation and ensuring adequate separation between mulch and structures.


• Implement Fire-Resistant Landscaping: Use fire-resistant materials for fencing and decks, and choose plants that are less flammable.


• Stay Informed: Regularly check for updates on local fire regulations and guidelines recommended by fire departments and insurance companies.

Wildfires are no longer merely seasonal occurrences; they are becoming a year-round threat that demands attention and proactive measures from homeowners. By being aware of the risks associated with mulch and adopting safer landscaping practices, residents can protect their homes and communities. Insurance companies are increasingly prioritizing fire-resilient properties, and with the stakes so high, now is the time for homeowners to take action. In a state where nature’s beauty is both cherished and feared, awareness and preparedness are essential to safeguarding lives and properties against the looming threat of wildfire disasters.

---

https://www.liveinsurancenews.com/common-mistake-homeowners-make/8559614/

---